Proper Fish Menu (Update 2025)
Proper Fish, located in Bainbridge Island, is renowned for serving some of the best fish and chips in the Seattle area. With a focus on simplicity and deliciousness, their crispy, battered British-style fish and chips stand out as a must-try. The portions are generous, easily feeding two people, and the addition of minty mushy peas provides a refreshing contrast to the fried goodness. While other menu items like cod chowder and fish tacos may fall short of expectations, the star of the show remains the fish and chips. The beer-battered fish is flaky, fresh, and enormous, offering a heavenly crunch and satisfying flavor. Despite occasional wait times, Proper Fish's authenticity and excellence make it a top destination for seafood lovers.
First Course
Premium Cod Chowder (Oz Cup)
Thick, creamy and delicious. We only use cream and butter as our liquid and is packed full of premium cod, finished with parsley oil, spring onions & oyster crackers
Premium Cod Chowder ( Oz Bowl)
Thick, creamy and delicious. We only use cream and butter as our liquid and is packed full of premium cod, finished with parsley oil, spring onions & oyster crackers
Onion Rings
Baby Gem Lettuce Caesar Salad
It's all about the dressing, whole baby gem leaves with house made croutons, well dressed in "Rick" Caesar dressing and shaved Parmigiano Reggiano
Prawn Cocktail
Prawn & Crab Cocktail with Gulf Prawn. Prawns, crab and radicchio with baby gem lettuce tossed gently in our house seafood dressing, micro greens and a dusting of paprika.
British Fish & Chips
British Frish & Chips "Seattle's BEST Fish & Chips - Seattle Times & ZAGAT" Wild, sustainable, longline, organic Bering Sea Cod. Served with house minted mushy peas and tartar sauce , freshly hand cut FAT chips, cooked twice for the perfect bite- Voted Best OF Bainbridge ,
Lobster Roll
Proper Legit Lobster claw and knuckle, held together with a dab of house mayonnaise, old bay spice, on a square sided butter toasted Essential Brioche Bun, finished with chives- served with Hand Cut Chips.
Fried Oysters
Lightly panko coated oysters, fried until "JUST COOKED" served with lovely chips & basil aioli
Fish Tacos
Two Traditional South Pacific Nayarit Bering Sea Wild Cod Beer Battered Tacos with glazed chipotle aioli, salted green cabbage, house Pico de Gallo cured pickled red onions, Cilantro Crema and house chips stick potatoes in a flour tortilla.
Fish Sandwich
Wild, sustainable beer battered Bering sea cod loin, with slow roasted thyme and rosemary tomatoes & caramelized onions with an arugula salad on a Macrina butter toasted potato roll.
Main Course
Kids Meals
British Fish & Chips KIDS
Named as best Fish & Chips in Seattle by The Seattle Times & ZAGAT. Local beer battered whole fillet, wild, sustainable, organic, line caught Bering sea Alaskan cod, hand cut fat, twice cooked chips, and house tartar sauce- Voted Best Of Bainbridge
Fish Bites
Wild Baring Sea Cod Loin, Sustainable, Hook & Line Fish Bites- Perfect for the kiddie winkies
Minty Mushy Peas
Northern Landen Minty Mushy Peas. You either love them or you hate them.
Hand Cut Chips
Punched by hand daily and carefully selected. Soaked, blanched and then cooked to order- Nice and big /", that taste like fluffy pillows of mashed potato with a crispy shell